You've survived your first day. As far as accomplishments go, this is certainly one of them.

Achieve this achievement by playing through the first day on the island.

Two days in a tropical paradise is more of a vacation than I had during the entire production of this game. I hope you know how lucky you are.

Achieve this achievement by playing through your second day on the island.

Finished the full game once through, did you? I *dare* you to try it again!

Achieve this achievement by playing through the whole game once.

You're really getting the hang of it now... or so you think.

Achieve this achievement by playing the game for one hour.

I think you might be enjoying this game a little too much.

Achieve this achievement by playing the game for five hours.

There's more to this game than just reading.

Achieve this achievement by playing one minigame.

If this were a carnival, you'd be walking away with a giant teddy bear. But it's not, so you get... this.

Achieve this achievement by having a perfect score in a minigame.

Come for the love story, stay for the spinning wheel.

Achieve this achievement by succeeding in a certain amount of minigames.

There are easy achievements, there are hard achievements, and there are silly achievements. Discovering an obscure path to deleting your save file and then actually going through with it, against my recommendation, is all three.

Achieve this achievement by choosing Trickster over Trapper.






THIS ACHIEVEMENT WILL DELETE ALL YOUR SAVE FILES
Choose Trapper as your love interest for this achievement.

You'll be in Trapper's Cave and you'll encounter Trickster.
This is what you should choose when talking to Trickster:
• Ask why you should
• Run to Trickster
This will result in a game over screen, then you click retry and repeat the same thing - choosing Trickster over Trapper. After some tries you'll get the achievement.

Still playing? You've officially loaded this game up more times than our own Game Director.

Achieve this achievement by retrying the game a certain amount of times.

You've shaken The Huntress' whole world with this decision. Your cruelty is shocking.

Achieve this achievement by eliminating Huntress.

After everything The Spirit has been through, she has to endure being eliminated, too? You're lucky she doesn't really care about any of this.

Achieve this achievement by eliminating Spirit.

You sent The Trapper packing? Sleep with both eyes open.

Achieve this achievement by eliminating Trapper.

What kind of monster eliminates The Wraith? He wouldn't hurt a fly! Please... disregard that skull he's holding.

Achieve this achievement by eliminating Wraith.

It's all fun and games until someone gets hacked to death.

Achieve this achievement by getting killed by Huntress.

You can achieve this in Wraith's route when you visit Huntress' Cabin:
• Beg for forgiveness
• Skewered death

I'm honestly surprised you lasted as long with The Spirit as you did.

Achieve this achievement by getting killed by Spirit.

During Spirit's route at the lounge you should choose these when talking to her:
• Booze it up
• Ask for Spirit to reconsider
• Smile more! You look beautiful when you smile

Does The Trapper play fair? No, not really. But that's why we love him! Or love to hate him--you'll have to decide that for yourself.

Achieve this achievement by getting killed by Trapper.

When talking to Trapper he'll show you his Hillbilly drawing, choose these options:
• It’s amazing
• Honestly
• Liar
You can also get killed by Trapper while being bad during his minigame where you have to find his traps. Not sure if this will count, though.

Didn't think he had it in him, huh? Well, think again.

Achieve this achievement by getting killed by Wraith.

At the very end of Wraith's playthrough you have to reject Wraith's love, then choose:
⠀• You’re not a killer

You just love pushing people's buttons, don't you? Let's hope it goes better for you in real life.

Achieve this achievement by getting killed by all the killers once.

Is that blood on your mask, or are you just happy to see me?

Achieve this achievement by playing through Huntress' route.

Revenge never looked as cute as it does in a sun hat and a black bikini.

Achieve this achievement by playing through Spirit's route.

What is going on in that weird little head of yours? No, actually--I don't even want to know.

Achieve this achievement by playing through Trapper's route.

What's hidden at the heart of this unraveling mystery? There's only one way to find out...

Achieve this achievement by playing through Wraith's route.

You didn't find love, but you found friendship that will last forever, and ever, and ever...

Achieve this achievement by getting rejected/friend-zoned by one of the killers.
To get friendzoned you have to pick wrong answers for the most part.

You've claimed your place beside The Huntress, in a quaint little blood stained cabin at the end of Lovers Lane.

Achieve this achievement by getting the good ending with Huntress.








Choose whatever you want before and during the quiz, these answers don't affect anything.

Huntress' location is the volleyball net on the beach, so pick that one.
• Imagination
• I'm sorry
• Accept the jerky
• Show a thing or two
Choose Huntress for storytime
• Join in on singing
• No way! How cool!
• Chuckle awkwardly
Choose Huntress for the date
• It's so... much!
• Grab a shashka
• Of course!
• Totally!
• UGH. As if...
• Thanks, but no thanks
• Any decisions at the cabin work
• Tell of your brush with death
• Fine, I'll tell a story
• Action
Choose Huntress for storytime and later on (obviously)
• Angler fish mask
• Any decisions
Mushroom quiz:
• LEFT
• LEFT
• RIGHT
• They ARE hot aren't they?
• Kill 'em all.
Choose Huntress
• Tidy up/Freak out (any works)
• HELL YES!
When you look for Huntress' treasure, go to Trapper's Cave through the Underground Tunnel
Afterwards, back in the cabin, pick these:
• What an honor!
• Of course!
• To start a family together
• Absolutely
• I LOVE YOU TOO!

The dark has never been so warm and welcoming as in the arms of your new bride, The Spirit.

Achieve this achievement by getting the good ending with Spirit.









Choose whatever you want before and during the quiz, these answers don't affect anything.

Spirit's location is the bar/lounge, so choose that.
• Virgin Daiquiri
• Dracula
• I'm sorry
• You've always been alone
• Nothing but darkness
Choose Spirit for storytime
• Say nothing. Hug her
• Who cares?
Choose Spirit for the date
• Thanks
• Sure, why not?
• Ask about the shards of glass sticking out of her
• Frustrated
• Be coy
• Ignore them
• I'm not the storytelling type
• Be gracious
• Stay sober
• Dark & Stormy
Choose Spirit
• Go up, maybe die
• Say something
Trapper quiz answers
• Rin Yamaoka
• A dragon
• Restaurant
• Black
• Not being seen for who you are
• Kill him

You and The Trapper, sitting in a tree, K-I-L-L-I-N-G.

Achieve this achievement by getting the good ending with Trapper.










Choose whatever you want before and during the quiz, these answers don't affect anything.

Trapper's location is the yacht, so choose that.
• You can’t choose
• Get rid of them
• I’m sorry
• No
• Follow quietly
• Magnificent
Choose Trapper for storytelling
• Now THAT’S a story!
• Honesty is important
• Laugh
Choose Trapper for the date
• Assume it’s a trap
• Don’t tell me what to do
• No
• He hasn’t proved his worth
• No
• Snoop around
• Hell yeah
• No, you’re remaining loyal to Trapper
• No
• It’s terrible
• Say nothing
• Fine, I’ll tell a story
• Pick adventure, then action
Choose Trapper for storytime
• Say nothing
• It’s another test
• Survival
• Maybe, maybe not
• I understand
Choose Trapper for storytime again afterwards
• Power
• Ask any questions you want
• Only if he promises not to kill you
• Drkest secret
• Your father sounds awful!
• What the hell is wrong with him?!
• No, you don’t believe him
• Choose any questions for Trapper's father
• Never
• A partner in crime
• Literally
• Yes
• Look around
• Finally, let’s do this!
• Yes, it was
• Depends on the person
• Refuse to kill Trapper’s father
• I would never kill any Macmillan
• Yes. I love Trapper!

You've reached inside The Wraith and done more than just touched his heart, you've connected with his soul.

Achieve this achievement by getting the good ending with Wraith.









Choose whatever you want before and during the quiz, these answers don't affect anything.

Wraith's location is the swimming-pool/beach, so pick that one.
• Goggles and snorkel
• Hands off
• Have some fun
• I’m sorry
• No
• Hold the bell delicately
Choose Wraith for storytime
• Ask about the story
• I would forgive him
Choose Wraith for the date
• Break the silence
• I have no idea
• Mix those potions!
• I remember my grandmother
• What’s the table for?
• Smile
• Truth or Dare produces the same result
• Hmm, great question
• Cactus
• Show me something
• You’re a hypocrite
• Say you had a great time
• Fine, I’ll tell a story
• Romance
Choose Wraith for storytime
• Ask what’s wrong
• Suggest throwing a frisbee
• Hug him
Choose Wraith again
• You could never disappoint me
• You can pick up the coin or not, doesn't matter
In Trapper's cave
• Look around the Cave
• Pick the up coin or don't, doesn't matter
• Quit while you’re ahead
• Tell him you’re pranking Wraith
In Huntress' Cabin
• Say you’re pranking Wraith
Back with Wraith
• What are we finishing?
• A statue of a horse
• Cactus
Trivia quiz answers
• Cetus
• The Zodiac
• Horologium
Then, just
• Accept Wraith's love!

Everywhere you look, you see heart-eyes staring back at you. It sounds quite freaky, if I'm being honest, but you do you.

Achieve this achievement by getting the good ending with each killer.

You've shoved a pin through the heart of a gorgeous butterfly and then locked it away to never be admired again. You jerk!

Achieve this achievement by getting the bad ending with Spirit.

Play through as if you'd want to get the good ending and at the very end where she kills Claudette choose these options:
• Spare him
• I never loved you

You've caught the spirit of the forest in a vile trap and then turned it into a pair of new boots. You devil!

Achieve this achievement by getting the bad ending with Huntress.

Play through as if you'd want to get the good ending and at the very end choose:
• LAUGH IN HER FACE!

You've broken down a mountain into a pile of dusty rocks, then turned your back and walked away. You villain!

Achieve this achievement by getting the bad ending with Trapper.

Play through as if you'd want to get the good ending and at the very end choose:
⠀• No, I don’t love Trapper

You've reached into the sky, plucked out a twinkling star, and crushed it between your fingers. You monster!

Achieve this achievement by getting the bad ending with Wraith.

Play through as if you'd want to get the good ending and at the very end choose:
• Reject him
• The others were right about you

You've broken the hearts of four bloodthirsty Killers and taken your place as a villain among villains. You really think that was a good idea?

Achieve this achievement by getting all the bad endings with each killer.

You really thought that if you unlocked every single branch, it'd take you to The Trickster's secret love scene, huh?

Achieve this achievement by getting all the endings with each killer.

Back for more, huh? So which one of these Killers do you love most? No, wait--don't tell me! I'll just look at your save file.

Achieve this achievement by starting a new game [...] times/restarting a game file [..] times.

EDIT: Might be fixed now.
NOTE: This achievement is bugged. To fix it, check out this guide:
Serial Killer Achievement Guide